Thank you all for participating in the poll and the competition held in the post “A Book Review – Bullshit Quotient“. Over a 100 people voted and mostly in favor of the views expressed by the author Ranjeev Dubey. Ranjeev has personally gone through the comments and chosen a winner. He has also expressed this thoughts on the various comments. Read below, as I am sharing an unedited version of his opinion.
“ My thought as I read through the thoughtful comments posted by your followers was mainly at the high level of comprehension here. Why we nevertheless allow this endless repetition of culpable double speak is a moot question. Why this clear understanding of the reality on the ground does not translate into a program of change is another moot question. I can draw your attention to the following nuggets that I particularly liked:
“The business of the company is to deliver value to the stakeholders/shareholders. Everything else is incidental. All the stuff about delivering value to customers is BULLSHIT. - M Seshagiri Rao:
“Small practices often have no audit trail. Accountability is ensuring that you understand and carry out the actions of the law, with ethical and moral actions. So, the laws are there, [but] the government is in the hands of those who thrive on power, regardless of having the right to vote, that doesn’t even matter…”- Joanne McNamara:
“As a cynical private investigator I have found that the bigger the lie, regardless of the circumstances, simply means that there are more person involved.”- Jeff Moy
“To add to the misery, a nation in need of an inspiring dream, is fed the empty corporate drivel”. - Amey Kawale
But at the end, the prize goes to the one who goes beyond the points made, to the next level so to speak. And for me, the winner is:
“Commercial organization sometimes fail to realize (or take the ostrich approach to the fact) that they don’t exist in a vacuum, but within an ecosystem where the (mostly competing) interests of companies, customers, employees, regulators, environment and the larger society are required to be optimized. This was the stated (though in a different way) objective of the concept of Trusteeship, which sadly has gone out of the window gradually after Indian independence.” – Deb.
Thank you all, and especially, thank you Debashis
Rajeev Dubey “
The winner of the competition is Debashis Gupta. Congratulations!
Debashis please email your address to me and we will send you the prize.